2022 – Jordana Dahmen(photos)

2021 – Katarina Schweitzer(photos)

2020 – Kim Layne(photos)

2019 – Shelby Brown(photos)

2018 – Tea Draganovic(photos)

2017 – Cassie Lewis(photos)(photos)

2016 – Sydney Halper(photos)

2015 – Claira Hollingsworth(photos)

2014 – Yvette Bennett(photos)

2013 – Marissa Wickland

2012 – Erna Palic

2011 – Erza Haliti

2010 – Jessca Hellwinkel

2009 – Melissa Weber (Semi-Finalist)

2008 – Tracey Brown

2007 – Amanda Rammell

2006 – Allyson Swan

2005 – Sade Aiyeku

2004 – Kimberly Glyn Weible (Semi-Finalist)

2003 – Lana Wright

2002 – Hilary Renee Ball

2001 – Elizabeth Barchas

2000 – Brooke Jennifer Gambrell

1999 – Amy Ambrose

1998 – Melinda Grassmick

1997 – Brandi Sherwood (1st runner up, then MISS USA!!!)

1996 – Tracy Yarbrough

1995 – Amy Michelle Tolzmann

1994 – Trenna Wheeler

1993 – Natalie Nukaya

1992 – Cheryl Lin Myers

1991 – Lori Jean Easley

1990 – Cindy Estey

1989 – Kelli Bean

1988 – Kay Kinsey

1987 – Vicki Hoffman

1986 – Kelli Catron

1985 – Sheri Rose

1984 – Valencia Bilyeu

1983 – Kerry Damiano

1982 – Valerie M. Stephan

1981 – Lori Ditch

1980 – Marta Vincen

1979 – Lori Jukich

1978 – Suzette Sanford

1977 – Leslie Kington

1976 – Cheryl Gilbert

1975 – Charlene McArthur

1974 – Darla Jan Dowden

1973 – Karen Hammond

1972 – Lianne Fulmer

1971 – Kris Riordan

1970 – Kathy Cravens

1969 – Karen Tall

1968 – Anna Evanson

1967 – Sandra Baldwin (Miss Congeniality)

1966 – Did Not Compete

1965 – Unknown Name

1964 – Dorothy Johnson (Semi-Finalist)

1963 – Did Not Compete

1962 – Kinne Holland

1961 – Delcene Rositer

1960 – Margie Davis

1959 – Pat Sherburne

1958 – Jeanette Ashton

1957 – Did Not Compete

1956 – Did Not Compete

1955 – Did Not Compete

1954 – Did Not Compete

1953 – Patricia Rose Carter

1952 – Cherrie Jean Lindsey